Maybe Amr's Right?

My friend Amr has told me repeatedly that I'm too picky. I contend that I'm not. I will now use the following as an example of not being too picky.

Last night I'm out at a party with my friend Dave. We're talking to a girl, and she says something (I forget what...) to which Dave replies: "Are you making fun of me?" The girl says that (I paraphrase), No, she doesn't make fun of people...that's mean. (continuing with, again paraphrasing) And she doesn't get sarcasm, either. It's not funny. Now she does find a lot of things funny, but not sarcasm.

Wow... I'm pretty sure that the only way she could have made herself less attractive would have been to casually mention that she had a penis.

So, no. Amr is not right.